"""Artist""" seething

There’s a lot of critique out there about the use of LLMs and GAI. Some of it more relevant, some underdiscussed and some plain hilarious. All this is worth a proper article on its own, but I wanted to share a quick thought on the meltdowns of self proclaimed “artists”.

Generative AI has made a lot of “artists” extremely angry. They are seething about being replaced by machines who have no “soul” and create “soulless slop”. Interestingly, it shows that even machine slop can replace their “art”, as it was never about the quality or creativity behind their work, but the mere fact that there was no other option, apart from using stock footage, to hire an “artist” to create the work for them. Corporations do not care, nor does the general public, which is a problem, but still.

Now that GAI models are powerful enough to create those illustrations based on a simple prompt and a budget of 3 USD and 10 minutes of time, there is little justification to pay an “artist” 200 USD to create the same corporate slop the machine can produce. It’s not like those “artists” were virtuosos, creating art of utmost quality and soul representing the depths and nuances of human existence, but rather slop out illustrations based on corporate guidelines, who by their very nature are anti human.

It is so funny to me that these people consider themselves artists, when all they do is sell their commodified illustrations. I hold the belief that everything can be art, as long as it is not created for (monetary or similar) profit, but rather through suffering of various kinds including the urge to create something, or for arts cause. Selling your services as an “artist” to a corporation to be used to manipulate the public for profit is nothing that deserves the title of “artist”, but what it is: a contractor.

These contractors will claim that “art is dead”, which is funny firstly because they reduce art to their capitalist slop which paid their rent, and secondly, because the majority of the “art” they created was already dead. They were just like the machines they so despise. They were given a prompt containing style, “corporate identity” and other constraints and subsequently created their “artwork”, leaving little room for creativity. The rest was mostly shitty simplistic logo designs a three year could come up with, plus proper proportions. If we want to give this current slop movement a name containing the word art, it wouldn’t be “dead art”, but a necromantic simulacrum That word again, but it fits so well for many things of art. I don’t know how one can be so proud of creating shitty corpo artstyle illustrations used to not overwhelm the reader with too much text and dehumanize them.

Lastly it should be said that all this in itself is a great piece of involuntary performance art and I can’t help but admire this picture of ignorance and all the gnashing of teeth. I hope the seething will continue and a lesson be learned.